Lex Favor Reo and Judicial Reasoning in Grounding Cable Theft on the Jakarta–Bandung High-Speed Railway: Decision 1255/Pid.B/2025/PN Blb 13 5
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26623/eef5ej84Keywords:
aggravated theft, lex favor reo, judicial reasoning, transitional criminal law, transport infrastructureAbstract
The theft of grounding cables from the Jakarta–Bandung high-speed railway raises an issue of intertemporal criminal law: the offence occurred before Law Number 1 of 2023 on the National Criminal Code took effect, but the judgment was delivered afterward. This article examines the application in Decision Number 1255/Pid.B/2025/PN Blb of the Bale Bandung District Court and the judges’ determination of the provision applicable to the defendant. It uses normative legal research with statutory, case, and conceptual approaches. The decision, legislation, and legal doctrines are analysed descriptively and analytically. The findings show that the defendant’s conduct fulfilled elements of aggravated theft. The court applied Article 477 paragraph (1) letter f of the National Criminal Code because its alternative fine was considered more favourable than the penalty under Article 363 paragraph (1) point 5 of the former Criminal Code. However, the reasoning has weaknesses. The reference to a forced door contradicts the finding that the defendant entered through a drainage channel. The judgment fails to explain the choice of imprisonment in relation to the available fine, while its operative part does not clarify the adjustment of the charge’s qualification. Nevertheless, the one-year prison sentence remains proportionate. This article contributes to criminal law scholarship by distinguishing the abstract advantage of a new provision (in abstracto) from its realisation at sentencing (in concreto). It argues that transitional judgments should expressly identify the method used to compare provisions under the lex favor reo principle and connect sentencing considerations to the type of penalty imposed.


