The Use of Police Power in Crowd Control: A Perspective of Proportionality and Accountability 5 0
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26623/enjjvc82Keywords:
Febri Riyantoni, Hafiz Nurdiawan WijayaAbstract
The use of force by the National Police of the Republic of Indonesia in crowd control may restrict citizens’ rights and freedoms. Therefore, such actions must comply with legality, necessity, proportionality, and respect for human rights. This study examines whether police regulations on the use of force conform to proportionality and human rights principles, and analyzes the limits of police discretion and legal accountability for violations of standard operating procedures. It employs normative legal research through statutory and conceptual approaches. Legal materials concerning the police, use of force, crowd control, proportionality, and accountability are analyzed qualitatively. The findings indicate that the use of force has a legal basis and a graduated mechanism. Nevertheless, implementation faces challenges involving crowd dynamics, discretionary authority, limited training, and weaknesses in supervision and evaluation. Discretion is necessary when officers respond to concrete situations, but it must remain within the boundaries of legality, necessity, proportionality, propriety, and human rights. Accountability for procedural violations should not be limited to officers involved in operations; it may also extend to command structures and supervisory responsibilities. This study proposes a three-phase analytical framework: proportionality functions as the evaluative criterion, discretion defines the space for operational decision-making, and accountability provides the mechanism for enforcement and institutional learning. The framework explains how legal norms guide police conduct while constraining the exercise of state coercive power. It also emphasizes that effective crowd control requires not only clear rules authorizing force, but also oversight, responsible decision-making, and remedies when police actions exceed lawful limits.


