Child Homicide and the Limits of Penal Escalation: Reconstructing Indonesia’s Child-Protection Policy 7 4
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26623/x9cs3m46Keywords:
Child homicide, ilicide;, criminal law policy;, child protection;, penal proportionality, socio-legal justiceAbstract
Child homicide exposes a profound tension in criminal law between the state’s duty to protect
children’s right to life and the limits of punishment as an instrument of prevention. This article
reconstructs Indonesia’s criminal-law response to violence against children, taking the 2016
reform of the Child Protection Law as its historical point of departure while considering the
entry into force of the new Criminal Code in 2026. It examines how homicide involving a child
should be legally qualified when general homicide provisions intersect with the special
prohibition of violence against children, and whether aggravated sanctions can provide
effective and rights-consistent protection. Using normative legal research through statutory,
conceptual, and socio-legal approaches, this study critically analyses Indonesian legislation and
peer-reviewed scholarship on filicide, child maltreatment fatalities, forensic proof, victim-
centred justice, and chemical castration. The article argues that the principle of lex specialis
cannot be applied mechanically. The appropriate charge depends on the statutory elements
proved, the causal relationship between the conduct and the child’s death, and the criminal law
applicable at the time of the offence. It further contends that Law No. 17 of 2016 should not be
interpreted as making chemical castration or electronic monitoring applicable to every child
homicide, because those measures are linked to specific sexual offences against children. The
article offers a dual-track model that combines accurate offence qualification, proportionate
sentencing, reliable forensic evidence, child-sensitive witness protection, and prevention-
oriented child-protection governance. It concludes that the legitimacy of penal policy depends
not merely on the severity of sanctions.


