Regulatory Asymmetry and the Illusion of Tax Neutrality in Islamic Finance: A Socio-Legal Analysis 1 5
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26623/6zr6zr53Abstrak
The rapid growth of Indonesia’s Islamic finance industry, a key pillar of national development frameworks such as Asta Cita and the National Medium-Term Development Plan (RPJMN), requires an adaptive, comprehensive, and legally certain tax regime. This article examines regulatory asymmetry in the tax treatment of conventional and Islamic financial instruments. Drawing on legal theory and socio-legal analysis, it argues that rigid application of the “form over substance” doctrine in positive tax law produces systemic inequities. These include double taxation in Murabahah transactions, the disallowance of depreciation expenses in Ijarah and Ijarah Muntahiya Bittamlik (IMBT) contracts, and the misclassification of innovative products, particularly the Syariah Restricted Investment Account (SRIA), through an inappropriate application of the mutatis mutandis principle. The article identifies three dimensions of tax neutrality: formal, substantive, and administrative. It demonstrates that neutrality may be achieved formally while remaining deficient in substance and administration, making tax neutrality largely illusory. Accordingly, it proposes a unified lex specialis to harmonize Sharia principles with fiscal policy, a cross-sectoral Islamic Finance Tax Task Force, and the cautious, statute-first integration of Sharia-based tax parameters into the Coretax Administration System (CTAS). Technological integration, it argues, must follow clear statutory authorization and coherent regulatory standards. These measures aim to address unequal tax burdens, improve legal certainty, and strengthen coordination between tax authorities and Islamic finance institutions. Ultimately, a fair and competitive Islamic finance ecosystem requires neutrality operating not only in legal form but also in substance and administration, thereby advancing fiscal justice and a level playing field.


